|
Tax credits as a form of state benefit
Tax credits may be characterized as either refundable or non-refundable, or equivalently non-wastable or
wastable. Refundable or non-wastable tax credits can reduce the tax owed below zero, and result in a net payment to the taxpayer beyond their own payments into the tax system, appearing to be a moderate form of
negative income tax. Examples of refundable tax credits include the earned income tax credit and the additional child tax credit in the U.S., and working tax credits or child tax credits in the UK.
A
non-refundable or wastable tax credit cannot reduce the tax owed below zero, and hence cannot cause a taxpayer to receive a refund in excess of their payments into the tax system. An example of a non-refundable tax
credit is the Saver's Tax Credit [1] in the U.S. or the former children's tax credit in the UK. Another example would be declared gifts made to registered charities in the UK under the current Giftaid scheme, which
attract tax relief (claimed by the charity) at the standard rate but which cannot reduce the donor's liability beyond the amount of tax actually paid by them in a given year. All tax credits in Ireland are
non-refundable.
Conservatives or libertarians, who generally favor tax cuts, often criticize refundable tax credits, saying that they are actually subsidies disguised as tax cuts. In other words, they are
spending in the form of direct transfers from the treasury to individuals, except that they are administered by the tax authorities rather than the agencies usually responsible for welfare.
|